Offensive Player of the Year: Bryan
Weimerskirch, La Roche College
Defensive Player of the Year: Eric
Hackworth, Penn St. Behrend
Newcomer of the Year: Anthony Crivelli, Penn
St. Behrend
Coach of the Year: Tyler Sheikh, Mount
Aloysius College
| FIRST TEAM | ||||
| Name | School | Pos. | Class | Hometown/High School |
| Bryan Weimerskirch *# | La Roche College | FWD | JR | Saltsburg, PA/Springdale |
| John L. Smith ^ | Medaille College | FWD | SR | Bath, NY/Bath |
| Chad Trozzi | La Roche College | FWD | SR | Lower Burrell, PA/Burrell |
| Anthony Crivelli | Penn State Behrend | FWD | FR | Cranberry Twp., PA/Seneca Valley |
| Eric Vunovic *# | Penn State Behrend | MID | SR | North Huntingdon, PA/Norwin |
| Dan Kennedy | Penn State Altoona | MID | SR | Langhorne, PA/Neshaminy |
| Jeremy Niemiec *+ | Pitt-Greensburg | MID | JR | Scottsdale, PA/Southmoreland |
| Eric Hackworth # | Penn St. Behrend | DEF | SR | Pittsburgh, PA/Shaler |
| Jacob Conde | Medaille College | DEF | SR | Bloomfield, CT/Bloomfield |
| Robert Fraino | La Roche College | DEF | SR | Pittsburgh, PA/Bishop Canevin |
| Jarrod Wassell + | Penn St. Behrend | GK | JR | Hollidaysburg, PA/Hollidaysburg Area |
| SECONDTEAM | ||||
| Name | School | Pos. | Class | Hometown/High School |
| Jimmy Belack + | Penn State Behrend | FWD | JR | Upper St. Clair, PA/Upper St. Clair |
| Karl Stephan | Penn State Altoona | FWD | SO | Milford, NJ/Delaware Valley |
| Parker Healy | Medaille College | FWD | FR | East Aurora, NY/East Aurora |
| Cory Carter | Medaille College | MID | SO | Mississauga, ON/St. Joseph's |
| Garrett Fiscus | Penn State Behrend | MID | SR | Russell, PA/Eisenhower |
| Tyler Irwin ^ | La Roche College | MID | SR | Gibsonia, PA/Pine-Richland |
| Patrick Chea | Mt. Aloysius College | MID | SO | Central Accra, Ghana/James Monroe |
| Michael Gee ^ | Hilbert College | DEF | SR | Dansville, NY/Arkport |
| Michael Jackson | Medaille College | DEF | SO | Bath, NY/Bath |
| Winston Crozier | Mount Aloysius College | DEF | FR | Mississauga, ON/Our Lady of Mount Carmel |
| Adam Forster + | Pitt-Bradford | GK | SR | Marietta, PA/Donegal |
| THIRD TEAM | ||||
| Name | School | Pos. | Class | Hometown/High School |
| Jon Davison + | Hilbert College | FWD | SO | Edwards, NY/Potsdam |
| John Imbimbo | Franciscan University | FWD | SO | Newtown, CT/St. Joseph's |
| Matt Hamister | Hilbert College | FWD | SO | Orchard Park, NY/Orchard Park |
| Ryan Luffey %+ | La Roche College | MID | JR | South Park, PA/South Park |
| Mike Raftu | Medaille College | MID | JR | New York, NY/Marta Valle |
| Joseph Duran | Franciscan University | MID | FR | Chantilly, VA/Seton |
| Xavier Cardona ^ | Mount Aloysius College | DEF | SO | Woodbury, CT/Nonnewaug |
| Trent Landis | Penn State Altoona | DEF | JR | York, PA/Central York |
| Garrett Storm | Penn State Altoona | DEF | SR | Mechanicsburg, PA/Cumberland Valley |
| Matt Smith | D'Youville College | GK | SR | Bergen, NY/Byron-Bergen |
| Tyler Brew | Medaille College | GK | FR | Brockport, NY/Aquinas |
KEY
| 2012 | 2011 |
| # First Team | % First Team |
| + Second Team | * Second Team |
| ^ Third Team | - |