Penn State Behrend senior forward Jordan Oberlander was named the Division III ECAC Women's Soccer Offensive Player of the Year, while Lion senior defender Rachel Weyand was also named to the first team. On the men's side, Franciscan University senior forward Leo Herrmann was named to the All-ECAC first team.

Oberlander finished the season ranked third in the nation in goals (30) and points (66). She also added six assists and six game-winning goals to her stat line. She was named the AMCC Offensive Player of the Year and was a first-team choice. Oberlander registered a point or more in all but two games, setting the program's single-season records for goals and points.

Weyand helped the Lions defense only give up three goals in nine conference games for a 0.33 goals-against average. Weyand also aided in six shutouts in AMCC action and eight overall. She started in all nine games in AMCC play and 16 out of 18 overall. 

Herrmann finished the year with 19 goals and eight assists for 46 points, all three marks break or tie the previous season-best at FUS, all held by Herrmann. His eight assists tie the program single-season assist record while the goal and point totals break the records. Herrmann posted seven game-winning goals, breaking his previous single-season mark and converted five of six penalty kicks, both are single-season records for Franciscan.